|
|
![]() |
||||||
|
|
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
Since the May 20, 2002, Ravenna City Council meeting several questions concerning the Nordic biofuels LLC ethanol production facility have been raised. We have attempted to address each question or issue completely given the information that is currently available to us. Certainly, there will be an on-going dialog as it relates to this important economic development project so we will continue to address issues as they are identified.
Over the coming days and weeks we hope to have additional information available to the community and to also schedule more public meetings where everyone has a chance to learn more about the project. Please feel free to contact us at the Ravenna Economic Development Corporation for more information.
Please submit any additional questions at the following link: Proposed Ethanol Plant Questions Form. These questions and answers will be posted as they are received and answered.
Over the course of the one year construction period, there will likely be hundreds of people involved in that process, but they will not all be on-site at the same time. A good number of the construction workers may actually come from the Buffalo County area as sub-contractors or temporary laborers. Consequently, many will be commuting to the work site from nearby homes. Others who relocate temporarily specifically for this project may seek motels or rental housing in Ravenna or surrounding communities like Kearney or Gibbon. Others may actually take up permanent residence in Ravenna. The increased activity related to construction of the plant should present welcome opportunities to existing businesses and local entrepreneurs but should not cause unmanageable stress to the community. |
| What if there was a backlog of wet distiller's
grain. Will there be storage facilities for it?
The plant will have equipment available to dry the wet material for shipment to other, more distant markets. With this capability the plant will be able to adjust its output to market demand. |
| Is Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC a legal entity in the State
of Nebraska?
After this question was raised earlier in the process, Nordic biofuels representatives discovered that their first filings had been done incorrectly. The papers have been refiled and Nordic biofuels will operate as a legal nebraska entity. |
| How long has this entity been doing business?
Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC is a newly formed corporation specifically for this project and potentially others in Nebraska. |
| Who is applying for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG)
and in what amount?
The CDBG grant will be coordinated through the Nebraska Department of Economic Development and its field service staff. The Economic Development Council of Buffalo County will assist the City of ravenna and Nordic biofuels to make a formal applications for the grant when the project is further along in its development timeline, probably in late July or early August. It is likely that the grant amount will be for $500,000. |
| What are the timelines involved, and what agency/bodies
are involved in reviewing and making decisions on the grant?
The CDBG process typically takes 90 to 120 days for approval. Public hearings will be a part of that process. The company under the supervision of and with the assistance of DED prepares an application. After the application is reviewed and all the attendant supporting documentation and requirements has been completed the governor also reviews the project and approves the grant. |
| What obligations would the grant impose on the city? What obligations
would a grant impose on Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC?
Each grant application is specific to the project applying for it so details regarding this project are not yet fully developed. In the case of economic development CDBG grants, the city acts as a pass through to the project. In other words, the funds are granted to the city with no requirement for repayment to the state and then either loaned or granted to the project. |
| Are there any requirements for the applicant to repay
the grant if any of the obligations are not met?
The grant documents have not yet been prepared. The terms of the grant/loan will be negotiated with the company sometime in July. |
| What will the grant funds be used for?
The decision regarding specific uses for the CDBG funds will be identified sometime in July. |
| What effect does the recent resignation of Tom Krueger,
President and Chief Operating Officer of Nordic biofuels have on this
project?
As is the case with most corporations Nordic biofuels has a policy that it does not discuss personnel issues. |
| It is reported that Nordic biofuels has had difficulty in obtaining capital
for a proposed $150 million ethanol plant project in Port of Longview,
Washington. how does that impact this project?
Ravenna is the beneficiary of the company's shift of emphasis from Washington to Nebraska. Because of this region's superior competitive environment, the company is focusing its first plant development here where it is more economical to construct their first facility. The referenced reports regarding the company's financing strategy are uninformed speculation. |
| An article from a daily newspaper dated June 10, 2002
states that the Longview WA project is not imminent. How many Nordic
biofuels ethanol plant projects are currently in process? Where
are they located and what is the current status of each? Does Nordic
biofuels have an ethanol plant operating? Are there any other communities
that are working with Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC?
Nordic has a successful history of developing, building and operating power plants. The Ravenna facility will be the first ethanol production facility constructed by Nordic biofuels, LLC. Nordic is considering a variety of other future opportunities but it is premature to publicly discuss things that may be in development. |
| Has anyone from Ravenna checked the credit of this LLC, the other Nordic
companies and/or the owners? What are the names of the banks and
creditors that they do business with? Has anyone from Ravenna verified
that the capital is available to complete the project proposed for Ravenna?
Who is providing the capital? Who are the people that make up this
LLC and how long have they been employed by this LLC? Is there an
organizational chart for Nordic biofuels of Nebraska LLC? Has anyone
from Ravenna seen this LLC's financial statements? Will this LLC's
financial obligations be legally guaranteed with the assets of other Nordic
companies and personal assets of the owners?
Nordic biofuels intends to provide as much information about their proposed ethanol plant to the public as is possible and reasonable. Naturally, a a large project like this generates a great deal of public interest which the company has earnestly attempted to address through its participation in community forums, numerous development meetings, and through its partners at the Ravenna Economic Development Corporation and the Development Council. Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC is part of the Nordic Energy Group, LLC which is headed by Mr. John Baardson. Mr. Baardson has visited Ravenna to meet with the community, and his associates are actively engaged in the monumental task of designing, financing and building a $97 million state of the art ethanol production facility. The Ravenna project has taken precedence over all other ethanol sites that had been previously considered by the company. Members of the State Department of Economic Development, the Economic Development council of Buffalo County, the Ravenna Economic Development Corporation, NPPD, and others have met with the company and its financing partners to review the project financing plan. The project will be privately financed with a combination of equity and debt financing in a package developed by the company. Naturally, much of the information associated with Nordic's financing plan must remain confidential, just as it is for any other privately owned business, including producers or Ravenna main street businesses. The company will continue to provide updates about the plants progress as they are appropriate, however in the term Nordic biofuels of Nebraska, LLC will be focusing its energy primarily on the tasks necessary to ensure the project's success. With a functioning 80 million gallon per year ethanol plant, both Nordic biofuels and the Ravenna area will be winners. |
| How many trucks will be coming out of and going
into the plant daily? Will any be using Ravenna's Grand Avenue?
There may be as many as 200 trucks making deliveries or off-loading product from the plant every day. Many of the trucks will be coming from the east or west along Highway 2 as well as some from the south which will use Navaho Road as their main access to the plant. However, some trucks coming from the north may be required to use Highway 68 as its route to the plant. Although fewer in number, there will be some increase in truck traffic on Grand Avenue. In addition to the road improvements planned for Navaho Road, there has been some discussion about creating a north by-pass to accommodate non local traffic. |
| What portion of the daily delivery of grain is recovered as wet brewer's
grain for local consumption?
Every bushel of input corn to the Nordic biofuels plant will come three products in roughly equal amounts - ethanol, wet distillers grain and CO2. The amount of wet grain by-product that is delivered to market in wet form will actually be determined by market demand. Some may be dried for shipment to more distant locations depending upon market conditions. |
| Who suggested that the project be kept a secret
from the public, from the time Dale Pohlman was contacted until shortly
before the public meeting?
The project was made public as soon as the company and the local development team had completed preliminary market evaluations that indicated a strong level of likelihood that the project could be successful. |
| When did the city become aware of the project? Were all the council
members informed at that time? Was that in a closed session?
Members of the community development team have been working on the project since the middle of March. That team was restricted during the early, exploratory part of the process to Dale Pohlman, Dale Johnson, and Gerald Reimers in addition to Ron Tillery. The council first heard of the project in detail at the community information meeting on May 13th, there was no closed session. |
| What has officially been done so far by the city,
township, county, and state as far as approving the project? What is left
to be done by the city, township, county, and state?
The first official action conducted by the city council in regards to the project was at the specially scheduled meeting on May 20th. There will be a variety of official city actions required in the future in addition to many activities conducted by the chamber, economic development group, and other community based organizations. Everything will be done with considerable community involvement and the overall best interests of Ravenna at the forefront. |
| Who suggested that this project be handled so
quickly by the city?
The pace of the project is dictated by construction schedules, environmental permitting processes, local annexation and zoning requirements, and the state operations deadlines to qualify for ethanol production credits. |
| Some people affected that are outside the city
limits, do not feel they have a right for their voice to be heard, because
they are not a citizen of Ravenna. Plus nothing has been discussed with
them. This is no way to treat a neighbor, in my opinion. Are these people,
and the lives that they have created for themselves expendable, in the
name of economic development?
Residents outside the community have been welcome at the community information meeting and the city council meeting that have been conducted to date. They will have opportunities to voice their opinions in future official and informal public meetings. |
| Are we interested in changing from the idea that
we are Nebraska's Hometown Hideaway? This plant is a good way to do that,
in my opinion. A plant of this size will dominate this town, even without
considering the future expansion of the plant.
Economic development that is consistent with Ravenna's heritage and resource base will help preserve the community's future viability and enable it to remain a Hometown Hideaway for future generations. |
| There has been a group formed, called the Ravenna
Area Citizens Concerned About Ethanol, to help in better understanding
the issues involved with this project.
The Development Council, the Ravenna Economic Development Corporation and Nordic Energy will welcome an opportunity to have a reasoned, honest dialog with any citizen or citizens group with the goal of providing and receiving factual information. |
| We feel the council is under no obligation to
meet the demands of Nordic biofuels in voting to go ahead with any aspect
of this project, before allowing ample time for the economic and environmental
studies to be done, and the citizens to be informed. The studies should
be done by someone other than Nordic biofuels. We feel the council is accountable
to the citizens of Ravenna and the surrounding area that they are affecting,
in taking the time to provide objective information and receiving public
input about the project.
Nordic biofuels has made no "demands" on the community or the city council, rather it has offered an opportunity that community representatives believed would be attractive and which they have agreed to fully research. They have agreed to work with the company to resolve development issues so long as it remains an attractive partnership to both parties. The entire predevelopment process will occur over the next four to five months giving citizens of Ravenna ample time to fully understand the potential impacts of the project. |
| There is another small town in Wisconsin that
has been working with an ethanol plant developer for several months now.
They have published the history if their experience on the internet, and
one could make a few telephone calls to make sure the information is accurate.
The internet address is http://www.menomonieethanol.com/history.htm.
The web site referenced is hosted by a small group of environmental advocates who oppose this project and is not necessarily representative of the entire community. Additionally, there is no connection between these two projects and any comparisons would be like comparing apples to oranges. |
| Almost all of the 100+ million dollars spent on
the plant will not be spent in Ravenna. The materials and labor will come
mostly from the outside.
Plant investment is now an estimate. The total project investment could be in the range of $97 million with construction costs in the range of $85 million. Although significant portions of specialized equipment will be fabricated elsewhere, there will be abundant opportunities for local contractors to participate in the construction of this project. Ranging from site work and paving to building construction, utilities, and roofing there are dozens of potential local contracts worth millions. |
| All return on investment in the plant will go out of the State.
Nordic biofuels of Nebraska LLC and its investors will share in the risk and the profits generated by the plant's operation. The largest single input cost to the plant is for corn - about $70 million - which will be paid to local producers. |
| I understand the trucking out of the plan will
be mostly handled by firms that are not based in our community. So the
return will go back to where they are based? We may have some drivers that
live here though.
Trucking opportunities will be created for both local and regional operations. |
| Will the farmers from the Ravenna community be
able to supply the 30 million bushels and gain the maximum economic benefit?
If not, what percentage? The Farm Service Agency may be able to help with
this?
The plant will purchase about $70 million worth of grain from farmers, large and small, or other sources in the area. |
| Nordic biofuels said they felt they would need
to go 40 or 50 miles to get the 30 million bushels needed. So if you consider
a 20 mile radius as the Ravenna community, and divide the area of the small
circle by the area of the large circle (40), you get 25% being supplied
by the farmers of the Ravenna community. At a nickel a bushel basis gain,
this translates to $375,000. If the radius of the Ravenna community is
15 miles and the larger circle is 45 miles, you then need 11.11% being
supplied by the farmers of the Ravenna community. At a nickel a bushel
basis gain, this translates to $166,668.
Nordic biofuels believes that it will consume somewhat more than 30 million bushels of corn per year. Over 300 million bushels are produced within a 50 mile radius of the proposed plan. The plant believes it will be able to contract for adequate supplies of grain without extending beyond a 50 mile radius of Ravenna, but Nordic intends to buy grain in as close of proximity to the plant as possible to avoid possible transportation costs. |
| Our corn basis in Ravenna has been fairly steady,
will the ethanol plant commit to a maximum fixed basis, based on the Chicago
Board of Trade, to guarantee the basis improvement?
The Ravenna corn basis has been consistently lower than many of the surrounding markets. While the plant will attempt to contract for grain at rates that allow it to be profitable, Nordic recognizes that local corn prices tend to increase by a nickel or more when an ethanol plant is built and they have factored that into their business pro forma. |
| Will Nordic biofuels be bringing in corn by train
to avoid bidding up for local grain?
Nordic has selected Ravenna in part because of the surplus corn supply in the market. It is their intention to purchase all of the corn for the ethanol plant locally. Nordic is also considering a corn load out facility that would enable them to purchase additional corn for its other planned facilities in the Pacific Northwest. |
| It has been mentioned that Nordic biofuels will
work with some farmers, are our community's smaller farmers going to be
offered something less, or nothing for their corn?
Nordic will work with farmers directly or with grain elevators in order to ensure timely and cost effective delivery of grain. |
| Nordic biofuels will not dry any corn? How will
the handle discounts for corn above 15.5%?
Nordic will address the questions of corn moisture discounts in the future. |
| Will Cargill stay in the community?
Neither Nordic nor The Development Council is aware of any relocation or sales plans involving the existing Cargill operation. |
| Investment and return for a truck stop that has
been talked about will come from outside our community? Will food offered
in a truck stop affect our local food businesses?
We are unfamiliar with specific plans for a new truck stop. It is possible that this or other new businesses may occur based upon individual assessments of the market's potential. |
| Electrical load increase rates? Cause more load
control for irrigation wells?
Neither Dawson Public Power nor NPPD have indicated that the new loads created by this plant would lead to residential or commercial rate increases or any other adverse affects on the community. In fact, there will be new infrastructure built to support this facility that could lead to greater local reliability. |
| Impact on natural gas price for the community?
Again, there is no correlation between this plant and local gas rates. |
| In understand the tax base will be 50% of the
hard costs, and will be taxed as personal property. This number will then
be depreciated over 7 years and be zero at the end of 7 years? Then the
only taxes paid, will be on the land, as it is now?
The county tax assessor will review the project at a future date. Initial estimates from that office indicate that the company should plan on a real property assessment of approximately 50% of the constructed value. |
| I understand that ADM is purchasing ethanol plant,
how will the future sale to someone like ADM affect our agreements with
Nordic biofuels.
It is important that contracts between the City of Ravenna and Nordic biofuels have transferability clauses in order to protect taxpayer's interests. |
| I understand that the Aurora plant is for sale,
and if it isn't sold, it will be shut down. Would the city be exposed to
losses if the plant would be shut down? How many years need to go by before
the city is not exposed to losses?
See above. |
| How will the average non farming citizen of the
area benefit?
Non farm residents will benefit from having further diversification of the economic structure of Ravenna. New jobs and potential new businesses or business expansion are likely results from this endeavor. The city's tax base will be expanded along with that of the local schools and the county adding strength to their respective balance sheets. As more than $2 million of local payroll ripples through the economy, Ravenna will become a more attractive community for other forms of investment not to mention its increased appeal to new families. Nordic biofuels has said they intend to become an active corporate citizen supporting community events, activities, and schools. |
| What percentage of the people that will work in
these new jobs, will actually live in the Ravenna area?
It is too soon to say how many existing residents will be employed at the plant, or how many new employees will move to the Ravenna area. The company says it intends to offer most of the 48 new jobs to people locally with a handful going to people with specialized backgrounds. Nordic will have a policy that requires some key employees to reside within the greater Ravenna area. A combination of resident employees and commuter employees is likely, but it is not possible to provide precise estimates, now. |
| What is the starting wage of the various positions
at the ethanol plant? I understand the more highly paid positions will
be filled from the outside?
The average wage for all plant employees will be about $40,000 per year excluding benefits. Nordic projects approximately 24 production workers at $35,000 and 8 maintenance workers at $40,000 per year. Rounding out the employment matrix will be 6 supervisors, 5 office/clerical, and 3 managers. |
| How much less use of the lake east of town would
there be, and the money that those people spent in Ravenna?
The plant should not have any adverse effect on the Ravenna Lake. |
| How much cost is there to the local township,
county, and state taxpayers due the incentives offered?
Nordic biofuels will be investing roughly $100 million to build the Ravenna plant. As partners with the company, the City of Ravenna, Buffalo County, and the state of Nebraska will provide administrative, technical and financial assistance, but the company assumes the predominant role for development. It is likely that the City of Ravenna will assist Nordic biofuels by redirecting some of the property taxes generated by the project back to qualifying uses such as land acquisition, site work, paving, etc. The precise amount of Tax Increment Financing available to the project will be determined later, after Nordic makes an official application through the Ravenna Community Redevelopment Corporation. The company will also apply to the state of Nebraska for a Community Development Block Grant, a process that will begin soon and will also provide several opportunities for public comment. Buffalo County has indicated a willingness to consider paving Navaho road from Highway 2 north to the project site, approximately 1.75 miles. The county would recover these costs through increased property tax revenues to the county over time. |
| Most plants manage their own waste disposal, what
are the costs for them vs. the costs for the city to do this? This is one
of the reasons it needs to be so close to the City?
The plant's wastewater treatment system is in the design process. Ravenna's city engineer and the company's engineering firm will collaborate to ensure a compatible system. The plant is 1.9 miles east of the city limits providing a significant buffer between it and other development and also strategically located to take advantage of rail access and other transportation infrastructure. |
| I feel it will be harder to attract employees
to existing businesses and to attract future businesses to the Ravenna
area that is not directly related to the ethanol plant, due to the ethanol
plant being so close. One of the things that we talk about when we are
interviewing people to come work for us in our business here in Ravenna,
is the quality of life for them an their family.
Other communities that have developed modern ethanol facilities report no significant adverse effects that limit economic development or quality of life. In fact, the reverse seems to be true. Spin off opportunities have been the result leading to improved quality of life and additional investments. |
| What is the dollar value of the tax increment
financing to the community or Nordic biofuels?
An economic impact report has been commission through NPPD economists that will address this area. |
| Will the city council obtain, at the developer's expense,
an environmental impact study done by Nebraska environmental engineer
consultants that are not employed by Nordic biofuels?
Before the plant can be constructed, Nordic Biofuels must complete, at its expense, all of the environmental permitting requirements of the state of Nebraska. The most significant permitting activity will be securing an air permit for the facility. This work will require the emissions from the project to be computer modeled to assure pollutant concentrations are below Nebraska Department of Environmental Quality ("NDEQ") significant impact level thresholds. Additionally, the equipment for the plant must meet Best Available Control Technology requirements of NDEQ in minimizing the discharge of pollutants from the facility. The planned wastewater discharge from the plant must also be reviewed and approved by NDEQ. |
| Has any council member visited an ethanol plant?
At this writing we are aware that the mayor and at least one other council member have visited the Aurora ethanol production facility. The Development Council and Nordic biofuels are currently exploring an additional trip(s) that will provide greater first-hand experience with similar operations. Not all ethanol plants are alike. It is important to visit plants that employ similar technology. |
| Has any council member visited someone living
near and ethanol plant?
It is our understanding that some council members have visited with plant neighbors. Additional visits will be planned. |
| Would anyone be affected if it was moved further
east between Ravenna and Cairo?
It is not feasible to consider other sites for the Ravenna plant at this time. |
| How many trucks traveling to the plant will come
directly through Grand Avenue, affecting the noise, street conditions,
and the safety of our children?
Nordic biofuels estimates that as many as 200 plant related trucks per day could be traveling area roads. These incoming and outgoing shipments could be oriented in a variety of directions, not all traveling through Ravenna proper. Nevertheless, it will be important for the community to plan for additional truck traffic and to make the necessary adjustments, if any, to ensure safety and good traffic flow. Additional revenues from the project's property taxes, franchise fees, use fees, and other sources could be directed to those issues. |
| What benefit to the city is there in taking over
the responsibility of the plant's sewage? If there are future problems
with the water quality, will the city be held financially responsible?
Nordic biofuels and Ravenna are jointly reviewing the sewerage system questions and will make a future judgment regarding design requirements and a rate structure necessary to finance any identified upgrades. |
| What makes thermal oxidizers "state of the art"
if they've been in use many years in the auto industry?
The company will answer the thermal oxidizer question. |
| Does the plant shut down if there are mechanical
problems with the thermal oxidizers? What monitoring will be done by the
city to assure the citizens that the thermal oxidizers are running at all
times and at the required temperature?
The company will answer plant operation question.
|
| What will the city council do for the residents
if the plant odor, sewage odor or toxic emissions residue becomes a problem
for any citizen; particularly the retired elderly or the very young?
The plant will be permitted by the state of Nebraska, which has policies and procedures for complaints. |
| If you would not want to live next door to an
ethanol plant, how can you ask your friends and neighbors to do so?
The plant will be designed and constructed to be a good neighbor to the community and it's surrounding residents. Like any agricultural, industrial or commercial activity - for example: BNSF, Leprino Cheese, or automotive and equipment dealerships - there will be impacts beyond its borders, and it will be among Nordic biofuels goals to ensure that the positive impacts far outweigh the negative. |
| According to the GI Independent, the EPA has raised
concerns about the toxic emissions not being regulated or exceeding existing
regulations. Factories that convert corn into gasoline additive ethanol
are releasing carbon monoxide, methanol and some carcinogens at levels
"many times greater" that they promised, the government says. Volatile
organic compounds being released by the ethanol plants include formaldehyde
and acetic acid, both carcinogens. Methanol, although not know to cause
cancer, also classified as a hazardous pollutant. Plants with emissions
above 100 tons annually are classified as major sources of pollutants under
the Clean Air Act.
There are a number of sources for factual information about ethanol and ethanol production. Please refer to the following organizations, publications or web sites, among others, for reliable data: The Ethanol Fact Book, and the Oxygenates Fact Book, both from The Clean Fuels Coalition, The Nebraska Ethanol Board, Todd Sneller, Administrator. Reprints from some of these publications will be made available at locations in the community. Frequently, media or other well-meaning individuals may rely on out-dated or out-of-context material that does not apply to this project. |
| Will Nordic biofuels provide air and quality monitors
for the city and surrounding area?
Nordic biofuels will comply with Nebraska's monitoring requirements. |
Additional Comments:
|| Top of Page ||
Copyright ©2000-02 Nebraska Public
Power District. All rights reserved.